Ask Not For Whom The BP Tolls, It Tolls For Thee (Revised)

The good BP that is – Baseball Prospectus – the annual forecasting bible aptly blurbed on the back page: “If you’re a baseball fan and you don’t know what BP is, you’re working in a mine without one of those helmets with the light on it” (yes, I’m egotistically quoting my egotistical self).

sc0009881d.jpgIt’s basically 573 pages of the sports almanac Biff Tannen finds in “Back To The Future II” so the material to mine is practically endless, and you will find it as useful on September 30th as you will today. But the aficionado often goes first to find the collapses that time, tide, and the theories of statistical reduction insist will afflict players you are counting on for your team, real-life or fantasy.

In short: BP does not like Josh Hamilton’s chances this year. In the list of the biggest falloffs in WARP (“Wins Above Replacement Player” – basically a measurement of how much
better or worse a player is than the absolute average Schmoe you could
stick out there at his position), it sees Hamilton dropping from 6.9 last year to 2.7 this. Mind you, this does not envision Hamilton winding up as a player-coach at Round Rock; 2.7 still makes him the fifth most all-around useful leftfielder in the majors. The computers still suggest he’ll drop from 32-100-.359/.410/.633 to 22-77-.294/.356/.509.

While similar plummets are predicted for Aubrey Huff, Adrian Beltre, Carl Crawford, and Jose Bautista (try 25 homers, because “if teams are smart, it could be May before he sees an inside fastball”), the most intriguing of them belongs to Austin Jackson of Detroit. As BP’s write-up notes, Jackson led all of baseball with a .393 BABIP (Batting Average On Balls In Play – in other words, what you hit when you actually hit it). Jackson struck out 170 times last year and had a mediocre on-base percentage of .344, and unless those numbers alter positively and profoundly, if his “BABIP” just drops back from Ted Williamsy to kinda great, they see his WARP collapsing from 3.6 to 0.2.

The BP formulae always tend to under-promise for pitchers. Dan Haren, Felix Hernandez, and CC Sabathia are the only guys forecast to win as many as 15 games this year, and that’s obviously an absurdly conservative prediction. Nevertheless it is chilling to see the computer spit out the following seasons for some of the game’s “name” twirlers:

Chris Carpenter: 9-5, 94 SO, 3.21 ERA
Phil Hughes: 8-6, 109 SO, 3.74 ERA
Zack Greinke: 11-7, 166 SO, 3.52 ERA
David Price: 12-8, 147 SO, 3.46 ERA
Tim Lincecum: 12-6, 190 SO, 2.74 ERA

It also doesn’t look so hot for some of the game’s closers, listed by predicted saves: Jose Valverde, 20; Carlos Marmol, 17; David Aardsma, 17; Brandon Lyon, 15; Brad Lidge, 15.

Last year’s biggest predicted collapse was Derek Jeter, and in fact the BP boys and girls turned out to have been optimistic. This year, the accompanying biography makes me look like Jeter’s most hopeful fan:

“Jeter pushed for a contract of four years and up, which suggests at least one of the following: (A) while Jeter may be the closest thing the modern Yankees have to Joe DiMaggio, he lacks DiMaggio’s sense of dignity; (B) never mind winning, it’s money that matters; (C) the emperor has no clothes but doesn’t know; (D) the emperor has no clothes but doesn’t care.”


Still, the PECOTA equations don’t see Jeter getting appreciably worse than last year (9-66-.281-.348-.377 compared to 2010’s 10-67-.270/.340/,370) but does see the once mighty warrior’s WARP sinking to 1.0. For contrast, Jeter’s great 2009 season had a WARP of 4.2, the top two shortstop numbers for 2011 belong to Hanley Ramirez at 4.8 and Tulowitzki at 4.7, and J.J. Hardy is a 1.9.

Having pilfered so much of their hard work, I feel it’s imperative to throw out some teasers to get you to buy this essential tome. Granted, at the BP website, the computers refine and refine these numbers even as the season progresses, but right now they somehow see Ryan Rohlinger absolutely tearing up the pea patch for the Giants this year, adore Javy Vazquez in Florida and Lance Berkman in St. Louis, and see potential breakout years for Sam LeCure, Brad Emaus, and Robinson Chirinos that even those players probably don’t.

And I’ll confess right now I had no idea who Robinson Chirinos was. Another reason to secure Baseball Prospectus 2011. However much you think you know about baseball, they know more than you do.



    As a video editor for 30 years ( www. ) and a FOK I decided to create a KO / Yankees music video for you for your private use and enjoyment. It is a token of appreciation for what you do. I was layed off and you provided both entertainment & inspiration during one of the most difficult years of my life( mom died, pet died and dad developed dementia). I would like to send you a DVD (Blu ray or regular). Please contact me at I think you will enjoy it! Please check out my web site if you have any qualms about this gift. It represents the kind of work I do and my “kosherness”.
    Tom Daigon
    Avid DS / FCP/After Effects Editor


    Glad to see WAR making its way into the blog discussion, although since I’m almost positive that a healthy Lincecum will strike out more than 190 batters this year, I’d expect his to be higher than BP projects.


    Hi Keith

    I dont know what you have against Jeter. Did he snub your you or something? He doesn’t have Dimaggio’s dignity? Look, I didn’t see DiMaggio play; I only remember him from those “dignified” Mr. Coffee commercials while Joe Jr. lived homeless. Are you aware that Joe’s own teammates didn’t care much for him? Phil Rizzuto on Mike and the Mad Dog said he preferred to play with Micky Mantle than Joe.

    Keith, is this personal?

  4. jeterandiborn62674

    Keith, I love your political views but it’s actually your views on baseball that are getting on my nerves. Yeah, I know, I’m Jeter’s biggest fan. But it’s not just that. You’re such a hand-wringer about the Yankees. You said they’d lose in the 2009 playoffs because of their three man rotation– wrong. And as for Jete– last year he hit .344 from September 14th on. But now you’re sounding off against Pujols with his contract situation. Beware of taking the side of the fat cat owners or just being a hardliner on things. Anyway I feel lost at 8 p.m.


    I liked the last sentence of the first paragraph better when it read: “. . . yes, I’m egotistically quoting my egotistical shelf.” (Parentheses omitted.)
    I know I’m easily amused, but sometimes even your typos are hilarious, Keith! 🙂

  6. giantsteps

    Lincecum’s biggest problem hasn’t been his pitching, but the Giants’ anemic hitting and the lack of bullpen support. (I’ve lost track of the number of no decisions he’s had where he left a game with a lead only to see the bullpen throw it away.) If the Giants’ hitting can respond to the changes (including the possible resurgence of Pablo Sandoval, who came into camp close to 40 pounds lighter than last year), I think BP may have to eat those numbers with fava beans and a fine Chianti. 😉

  7. promof2012

    Yeah, I know, I’m Jeter’s biggest fan. But it’s not just that. You’re such a hand-wringer about the Yankees. You said they’d lose in the 2009 playoffs because of their three man rotation– wrong. And as for Jete– last year he hit .344 from September 14th on. But now you’re sounding off against Pujols with his contract situation.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s